On Pillowfort, and a musical theater blanket box
Pillowfort is shutting down in just under 2 weeks. I'm not surprised about the news because its financial situation was always precarious, but it's still a big loss and I'm sad to see it go. I never really got a good foothold there because social media sites feel limiting and superfluous compared to just posting stuff to this website. If wasn't here, I probably would have used it more.
Pillowfort got a lot of things right! It's the only Tumblr-like website I've seen that preserved and improved on the format. I thought the commenting system was very thoughtfully implemented in particular. The alternatives I've seen floating around have mostly been on the fediverse, which just means Twitter with a new coat of paint. Disgusting. Dreamwidth has also been proposed as an alternative, and it's certainly better in that it's not another fucking microblogging website, but it's not quite the same without reblogs.
Pillowfort U-Haul is currently working on archiving all the blanket box prompts and encouraging people to fill them out as the shutdown approaches. They're great blog filler, so I saved some to put here. Today I'm doing the musical theater blanket box because I haven't talked about theater here yet!
1. What are some musicals you like?
This was originally two questions split by tone (serious and lighthearted), but I got rid of that because so many shows can't be neatly categorized that way. I also have a hard time picking favorite musicals because I will enjoy nearly any show if I see a good production of it. So this is a list of a few that I've seen and would recommend!
- Cabaret - Seen the Sam Mendes production that was filmed for TV, not in person (yet). I really loved Jane Horrocks' performance as Sally, and of course Alan Cumming has gone down as one of the Emcees of all time. The entire production had a looming sense of dread hanging over it, which I think is appropriate for the subject matter.
- Cats - Seen twice, seen the 1998 DVD version, and played in the pit. I will see it every time it's performed near me. People are usually disappointed because they want to understand it, but there's nothing to understand! It's people dressed like cats and doing the hardest choreography on Broadway! If you just hate it because you think it's cringe, you have no taste and hate having fun.
- Hadestown - Seen twice, a local high school production and the Broadway tour. I didn't really "get" it until I saw it live, partly because I can't get myself to like Reeve Carney as Orpheus in the original Broadway show. Both casts that I saw were great, though. The score makes very effective use of the onstage pit, including some truly nasty trombone.
- Hello, Dolly - Played in the pit. I'm definitely biased towards Dolly since I've been in a production, but it's a hit for a reason! I listened to the Pearl Bailey and Cab Calloway recordings a lot while I was practicing.
2. What is your favorite movie musical?
My favorite movie adaptation of a musical is Chicago because it enhances the musical elements instead of just reproducing or (worse) downplaying them. I also love Mamma Mia. I can forgive that Pierce Brosnan can't sing because everyone is clearly having a lot of fun, which is the most important feature of Mamma Mia.
In the way of movie musicals (movies that are musicals but not based on an existing stage production), Moulin Rouge comes to mind. What a fever dream of a movie. My favorite animated movie musical that I can think of right now is Prince of Egypt. I thought the stage adaptation was a downgrade.
Whenever I get the willpower to watch more movies, I'd like to get more into Indian movie musicals!
3. What musicals do you want to see?
I'm planning on seeing Maybe Happy Ending when it comes around on tour at the Buell next year. I'm also hoping to take a weekend trip to Salt Lake City to see Operation Mincemeat because it's not stopping in Colorado. Some other shows that I'd like to see on tour this season are Buena Vista Social Club, Shucked, and Beetlejuice, finances permitting.
I wish I could have seen Cats: The Jellicle Ball, because (as established) I love Cats and this was such a fun spin on it. I love non-replica productions and wish there were more for Cats, since it's such a weird and open-ended musical to begin with. I was a little annoyed with all the people praising it by saying that it "fixed" Cats because you can only get a show like that if you love the source material.
I also wish I could have seen the extremely short-lived Lestat, because of the mystique.
4. What musical do you think is overrated?
I don't care for Wicked that much, movie marketing machine notwithstanding. There are a lot of themes it tries to address without fully committing to them. There is a lot of fun music though!
5. What musical do you hate?
I'm a professional and recreational Hamilton hater. Also could have done without Miss Saigon.
6. What musical have you seen most recently?
In person, I saw the CU Boulder production of Sweeney Todd in October and it was phenomenal! It was a very campy production compared to some of the Broadway stagings. There was so much color and life, which added more contrast once Sweeney started murdering everyone. The actor playing Mrs. Lovett was a show-stealer and I hope she finds continued success in her career.
The most recent filmed musical I saw was the proshot of the 2023 Broadway production of Merrily We Roll Along. I loved the unabashedly midcentury set and costumes. The book is distractingly janky, but the actors did a great job trying to make you forget that normal people don't talk like that. Daniel Radcliffe gave a very endearing performance as Charley. His Franklin Shepherd Inc. was the highlight of the show for me. Lindsay Mendez was also wonderful (as usual) and asserted herself even when the script stopped giving her interesting things to do.
7. What are some of your favorite songs from musicals?
I don't listen to showtunes out of context. Instead, please enjoy the Jellicle Ball version of Skimbleshanks the Railway Cat, performed by the amazing Emma Sofia.
8. What musicals would you like to see made?
At this point I'm just tired of movies getting turned into musicals getting turned into movies, so probably less of that. This will never happen.